A pair of recent pieces examined games where player reception has outpaced critical consensus, focusing on two distinct subgenres. One compilation highlighted Soulslikes that earned stronger user scores than critic ratings, while another surveyed Metroidvanias following the same pattern. The lists suggest audiences have found merit in titles that didn't necessarily align with professional review scores, a common occurrence across the industry where player expectations and critical metrics sometimes diverge.
- Player-favored games in both Soulslikes and Metroidvanias show measurable gaps between user and critic scoring.
- These roundups serve as guides for players seeking community-endorsed titles rather than critic-driven recommendations.
All coverage
Soulslikes With Higher User Scores Than Critic Scores
If you're looking for community-endorsed experiences, I recommend you try these ten Soulslikes where the user score is higher than the critic score.
Metroidvanias With Higher User Scores Than Critic Scores
If you're interested in finding titles loved by the players, check out these ten Metroidvanias where the user score is higher than the critic score.